Watched Ender’s Game last night.
It was a solid movie. Not especially great, but not terrible. I’ve seen a few comments from reviewers to the effect that if the movie focused on the Battle Room sequences and on the space battles, excluding the psychological elements and the ethical questions, it could be a great spectacle movie. Or by doing the opposite, and focusing heavily on the psychology and the inner turmoil of the titular character, and the ethical issues, it could be a great dark psychodrama.
As it stands, the movie is compressing too much information into too short a time. There is no progression and no time to show the growth of the characters. There is no time to dwell upon any of the cruelties and assaults perpetrated against Ender. Ender is puppetized, existing only to take the next step and propel the plot. And, what should stand forth as the saving grace, the Battle Room scenes, are pared down to the minimum, and lack the context to understand or care.
The book, flawed morality1 and potential Hitler apologia2 status aside, is a powerful and compelling story. One of the triumphs of the book is how it places you at once within the mind of a child, and also as an observer with an awareness of just how deliberate the cruelties are. The movie fails to capture the internal torment of Ender. It also fails to make the scenes of children at war in the Battle Room thrilling.
The acting is probably the best part of the movie. Hailee Steinfeld and Moisés Arias particularly shine, but everyone is a credit to their role. It’s a shame the movie feels so abbreviated, that so many moments are excised rather than allowing the actors and actresses the time.
Recommended, but keep your expectations low. Reading the book first will make more of the movie comprehensible.